Setanta

Buyer's guide

AI implementation partner vs consultant, for a steel company.

Quotes, mill certs, remnants and dispatch either get run better, or a new tool sits unopened. A privately run US industrial company of 50 to 600 people has four ways in: its ERP vendor's AI features, a large consultancy, an in-house hire, or an implementation partner. Each fits a different job.

Gary O'Neill, founder and CEO of Setanta

Gary O'Neill, founder of Setanta, an Anthropic Partner in Wilmington, North Carolina.

Why it matters

One process, run well, beats a tool nobody opens.

At a steel service center, the inside sales rep reads the RFQ, checks stock and remnants, finds the mill cert and prices the order. At a fabricator, the estimator reads the drawings before anyone can quote. Pick the path that fits that work, and the best person's way of doing it reaches every seat.

Why it matters

One process, run well, beats a tool nobody opens.

At a steel service center, the inside sales rep reads the RFQ, checks stock and remnants, finds the mill cert and prices the order. At a fabricator, the estimator reads the drawings before anyone can quote. Pick the path that fits that work, and the best person's way of doing it reaches every seat.

Path 1

Should you turn on the AI features in your ERP?

Start there if they cover the job. Your ERP or industry software vendor knows its own data, and its add-on is often the shortest step for a task that lives inside that system. It fits less well when the work starts outside it, in an emailed RFQ, a PDF mill cert or a customer's own shorthand.

  • Fits when: the task starts and ends inside the ERP, such as a report or a lookup on your own inventory.
  • Fits less well when: the work crosses the inbox, the ERP and a person, such as turning a customer's email into a priced quote.

Path 2

When does a large consulting firm make sense?

When the change is large, with many plants, many systems, a company-wide roadmap, and the budget and staff to match. For a company of 50 to 600 people that wants one process working first, a large team can be more than the job needs, and the people who sell the work may not be the people who build it.

  • Fits when: you need a program across sites, a strategy document for the board, or many people on call.
  • Fits less well when: you want one quote desk or order desk running better first, with the person you meet doing the work.

Path 3

Should you hire an in-house AI engineer?

Hire when you have a clear first problem, data that can be reached, and enough work to keep one person busy for years. That person then carries the build, the training and the upkeep alone. Many companies do both. A partner builds the first process, and an internal owner keeps it running.

  • Fits when: someone inside already knows both the work and the tools, and has time to own it.
  • Fits less well when: nobody yet knows which process to start with, or the one hire would sit outside the quote desk and the shop floor.

Path 4

What does an AI implementation partner do?

A partner builds one process end to end, inside the systems you already run, then trains your team to run it. At a steel service center that might be RFQ to quote, with Claude drafting and the inside sales rep approving every price. At a fabricator it might be reading drawings for the estimator. You own what is built.

  • Fits when: the work crosses people and systems, and you want one number to move on your own baseline.
  • Fits less well when: your ERP add-on already covers the job, or the process owner has not agreed anything should change.

Compare

Four paths, five questions.

ERP add-onLarge consultancyIn-house hireImplementation partner
Who does the workYour vendor's product, set up by your teamA firm's team, often several rolesOne person you hireThe partner, with your best person
How soon one process runsSoon, for tasks inside the ERPAfter discovery and a roadmapAfter hiring and onboardingScoped in the Operating Diagnostic, one process first
What you own at the endA licence to the featureA roadmap and what was built, per the contractWhat that person builds, while they stayThe workflow, in your own accounts
Fit with the ERP and inbox you run todayStrong inside the ERP, weaker in the inboxBuilt to plan, across systemsDepends on the personBuilt around both
Who approves outputsYour teamYour teamYour teamYour team, a named person on every price, order and commitment

Where we fit

Where we are a good fit, and where we are not.

Setanta is an Anthropic Partner. We help privately run US industrial companies of 50 to 600 people put Claude to work, starting with steel service centers and fabricators.

We are new to steel, and we have no published steel or industrial client yet. A quote-heavy business we work with took a client proposal from 5 days to 5 minutes.

We are a good fit for one process working first, with a person approving every output and everything left with you. Claude licences are billed to you by Anthropic, with no markup from us. If your ERP vendor's add-on covers the job, use it.

First step

Start with one process.

1. Operating Diagnostic. Free. We look at how your team works today and find the process worth fixing first. If it is not the right time, we say so.

2. Build. One process, run the way your best person does it. Durations are scoped in the Operating Diagnostic. We do not publish prices.

Questions

Asked before every first call.

Is an AI implementation partner the same as an AI consultant?

They overlap. A consultant often advises on what to do. An implementation partner builds the workflow inside your own systems, trains your team to run it, and leaves it with you. Ask any firm who does the work and what you keep at the end.

Should a steel service center use its ERP vendor's AI add-on or a custom AI workflow?

Use the add-on when the task lives inside the ERP. Consider a custom workflow when the work starts in the inbox, such as an emailed RFQ, a mill cert request or a remnant question, and has to reach the ERP and a person before it is done.

Should we hire an AI engineer or work with a partner?

Hire when you have a clear first problem, reachable data and years of work for one person. Work with a partner when you want one process running first and your team trained to keep it going. Many companies do both.

Who does Setanta work with?

Privately run US industrial companies of 50 to 600 people. Steel service centers and fabricators come first, then heavy equipment OEMs and dealers, industrial freight carriers and heavy manufacturing. We are based in Wilmington, North Carolina, and we are an Anthropic Partner.

Does Claude set our prices or release our orders?

No. Claude drafts and shows the information it used. A named person approves anything that changes price, inventory, quality or a customer commitment.

Start with one process.

Operating Diagnostic. Free. We look at how your team works today and find the process worth fixing first. If it is not the right time, we say so.

Book a call